BVBook Verdict

Book Club Guide

Dept of Speculation

by Jenny Offill · 2014 · Literary Fiction

Key themes

  • The marriage that nearly didn't survive — told from the middle of almost not surviving
  • The woman artist and the impossible calculus of work and family
  • The second person as a way of dissociating from pain you are living through

About this book

A marriage under strain is told in fragments — aphorisms, observations, diary entries — by a woman who refers to herself in the third person as 'the wife.' Offill's novel is formally radical and emotionally precise: a portrait of a relationship, a creative crisis and the ordinary catastrophe of trying to live alongside another person.

Published in 2014, Dept. of Speculation was shortlisted for the Folio Prize and the Pen/Faulkner Award. Offill said she wrote it in fragments because she was living in fragments — unable to sustain continuous thought while raising a young child.

Discussion questions

  1. The novel's narrator refers to herself at times as 'the wife' in the third person. What does this grammatical dissociation achieve — and when does it shift back to 'I'?
  2. The novel is full of quotations, facts and aphorisms alongside the personal narrative. How does Offill use this material — as a way of managing pain, as evidence for arguments, or as a formal strategy?
  3. The marriage almost breaks over an infidelity. How does Offill show the recovery — is it fully convincing, or does the novel leave doubt?
  4. The novel is preoccupied with the impossibility of being both a good mother and a serious artist. How does Offill engage with this question — does she resolve it?
  5. Dept. of Speculation is very short. How does Offill's compression serve the subject — and what does leaving things out do for the emotional weight?

Get the book

Links open an Amazon search. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Read together or read next

Books that make a good pairing or natural follow-up.

Reading it with your group?

Get Dept of Speculation

As an Amazon Associate and Bookshop.org affiliate we earn from qualifying purchases.