BVBook Verdict

Book Club Guide

Death Comes for the Archbishop

by Willa Cather · 1732 · Historical Fiction

Key themes

  • The Southwest as a landscape that shapes and resists those who come to it
  • Two men — bishop and vicar — and the bond of a shared faith and shared life
  • Catholicism in New Mexico — a faith meeting older faiths already present

About this book

In 1851 French Bishop Latour and his friend Father Valliant are dispatched to New Mexico to reawaken its slumbering Catholicism. Moving along the endless prairies, Latour spreads his faith the only wa

Published in 1927, Death Comes for the Archbishop is based loosely on the life of Archbishop Jean-Baptiste Lamy, the first bishop of Santa Fe after the American annexation of New Mexico. Cather researched extensively in the Southwest and was drawn by the quality of the light.

Discussion questions

  1. The novel is structured as an episodic series of vignettes rather than a conventional plot-driven narrative. What does Cather achieve through this loose, legendary structure — and how does it relate to the landscape the novel describes?
  2. Bishop Latour and Father Vaillant are very different men — one reserved and aesthetic, one energetic and earthy — yet their friendship is the novel's deepest subject. How does Cather develop this bond across decades?
  3. The novel engages with the Indigenous and Hispanic Catholic communities Latour encounters. How does Cather develop these cultures — with respect, with condescension, or with something more complicated?
  4. The Southwest landscape is rendered with extraordinary physical specificity. How does Cather use this landscape — as backdrop, as character, or as something that actively resists the civilising mission Latour represents?
  5. Death Comes for the Archbishop is one of Cather's most celebrated novels. What does it do that My Ántonia and O Pioneers! cannot — and what is the elegiac quality of its late Cather style?

Get the book

Links open an Amazon search. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Read together or read next

Books that make a good pairing or natural follow-up.

Reading it with your group?

Get Death Comes for the Archbishop

As an Amazon Associate and Bookshop.org affiliate we earn from qualifying purchases.